?

Log in

 
 
25 May 2009 @ 10:24 pm
Round 4: Challenge 6: Results  
Round 4: Challenge 6: results!
Thanks everyone for the votes..


Eliminated:
Photobucket by allllure with -4 votes - I'm sorry to see you go.

People's Choice:
Photobucket by mayush17 with +3 votes - Congratulations!


If PC would like a banner, comment to this post.


Tally (find your number here):
1. -3+1 > -2
2. -1
3. -4
4. +3
5. -2+1 > -1


Comments:

Negative votes:

#01 - The icon is too dark.
#01 - the coloring is too pink, the crop is too close.
#01 - The crop doesn't work that well, and the icon is blurry

#02 - I don't understand the theme of this icon .. On the left part the smudge is not well done. And could use a bit more contrast.

#03 - Too dark, makes Hayden's facial features unrecognizeable
#03 - The coloring is too red.
#03 - the icon is too dark.
#03 - Coloring is too dark, you can't really see her face

#05 - there is too much going on in the icon and it distracts your attention away from hayden.
#05 - the two textures don't fit well and the coloring is very desaturated.


Positive votes:

#01 - nice crop and coloring.

#04 - Great use of textures and colors
#04 - the rotation works really nice.
+1 vote > no reason added

#05 - Nice creative icon.